Metaphysics

Can a stone have a soul?

This idea's video is in the works

Sources
Thales of Miletus

The magnet has a soul

According to Aristotle, Thales apparently said the magnet has a soul because it attracts iron. Aristotle also suggests that Thales perhaps thought all things are full of gods because, as some said, soul is interfused throughout the universe.

ancient testimony · Aristóteles, On the Soul (De anima) 1.2 405a19

This idea opens onto 3 paths

Metaphysics · soul (psychē) · hylozoism · the divine

What is claimed and why

  1. Aristotle reports that, apparently, judging from what is related of him, Thales said the magnet has a soul because it attracts iron (Hicks renders the clause as a condition, 'if it be true that he affirmed'; the IEP, as a cause); Diogenes Laertius adds that, according to Aristotle and Hippias, Thales attributed a soul or life even to inanimate things, arguing from the magnet and from amber. ancient testimony
    Aristóteles, On the Soul (De anima) (tr. R. D. Hicks) — 1.2 405a19
    if it be true that he affirmed the loadstone to possess soul, because it attracts iron
    Diógenes Laercio, Lives of Eminent Philosophers (tr. R. D. Hicks) — 1.24
    Aristotle and Hippias affirm that, arguing from the magnet and from amber, he attributed a soul or life even to inanimate objects.
    Diógenes Laercio, Lives of Eminent Philosophers (tr. José Ortiz y Sanz) — §3
    Aristoteles y Hipias dicen que Tales atribuyó alma á cosas inanimadas, demostrandolo por la piedra iman y por el electro.
    Patricia O'Grady, Thales of Miletus (Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy) — §7 · consulted; copyrighted text, not reproduced
  2. Aristotle mentions those who say that soul is interfused throughout the universe and suggests that this is perhaps why Thales supposed all things are full of gods. ancient testimony
    Aristóteles, On the Soul (De anima) (tr. R. D. Hicks) — 1.5 411a7
    which is perhaps why Thales supposed all things to be full of gods
    Diógenes Laercio, Lives of Eminent Philosophers (tr. R. D. Hicks) — 1.27
    the world is animate and full of divinities
    Patricia O'Grady, Thales of Miletus (Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy) — §7 · consulted; copyrighted text, not reproduced

Profile: Thales of Miletus

Optional questionSkip

According to Aristotle, why did Thales apparently say the magnet has a soul?

Answer later